Listeners:
Top listeners:
play_arrow
Atom Radio
play_arrow
Best of Brakfast Episode 174 Yana Bolder
It’s Top 5 Tuesday on Atom Radio, and today we’re taking a look at a story that’s part legal drama, part council politics, and surprisingly relatable for anyone who’s ever been rejected for a job. Here’s the scoop behind one of this week’s biggest talking points.
1. The Claim That Shook the Council
James Sheehy, 29, applied to be town clerk at Lymington and Pennington Town Council in March 2024. Despite seven years of experience and the required professional certificate, he didn’t have a relevant degree. The council turned him down, but that was just the beginning.
2. Feeling the Age Pressure
Mr Sheehy argued that the job’s requirement of 10 years’ managerial experience effectively discriminated against younger applicants. At 29, he was just shy of the decade mark, which meant anyone aged 31 or under was automatically disadvantaged. The tribunal agreed this was indirect age discrimination.
3. Reconsideration Without Success
On the advice of the retiring town clerk, the council agreed to review Mr Sheehy’s application along with four others. Even so, he wasn’t shortlisted. Councillors cited his shorter tenure in previous roles and felt other candidates were better suited to the position’s demands.
4. The Tribunal Verdict
Judge Dawson ruled that while the council’s shortlisted candidates were suitable, the rigid 10-year experience rule wasn’t reasonably necessary. Mr Sheehy was awarded £2,792 taxpayer-funded compensation for injury to his feelings—proof that sometimes bureaucracy has consequences beyond paperwork.
5. The Aftermath and Lessons
Councillor Colm McCarthy, the town mayor, acknowledged the time and resources the case consumed but agreed the tribunal’s judgment was fair. For anyone reading this, it’s a reminder that job applications aren’t just about your CV—they’re about rules, perception, and sometimes, a little bit of luck.
This story shows why Top 5 Tuesday isn’t just about music—it’s about the headlines and the stories behind them. From unexpected tribunals to age discrimination debates, these are the topics that get people talking, and we’ll be keeping our ear to the ground for the next one.
A commuter train has derailed near Barcelona after a retaining wall collapsed onto the tracks. Spanish emergency officials say the train driver has died, and twenty people have been injured, four of them critically. The derailment comes just two days after a separate train collision in southern Spain killed forty two people and injured dozens more. A fifteen year old boy has been stabbed to death in woodland near a […]
